It is crucial to conduct thorough research before installing a new roof. You should always go through each type of roof. Then, shortlist a few. It is also okay to think about it long and hard and finally make a decision.
The two most common roof choices among homeowners are usually metal roofs and shingle roofs. It can be a little difficult to choose between these two. At Jensen & Son Roofing & Restoration, we help homeowners make choices that suit their style and budget.
We have decided to cover all the advantages and disadvantages of these roofs in this blog.
How Are Metal Roofs Better Than Shingle Roofs
Metal roofs always look like a complicated choice. It needs special building methods, builders who have a lot of experience, and more small parts and pieces to make it successful.
You start to wonder, “Why is it so popular? Why do some people pick metal roofs over shingles all the time?”
We have broken down all the things that make it awesome with the help of a trusted Roofing Service.
Pros of Metal Roofs
- Lifespan:
- Expected to last at least 50+ years.
- Lasts much longer than asphalt shingles (15-20 years).
- Lower Long-Term Cost:
- Less expensive over time because ONE metal roof outlasts THREE shingle roofs.
- Example: $17,457 (metal) vs. $26,211 (shingles) over 60 years.
- Fire Resistance:
- Class A fire-rated and non-combustible.
- Highly resistant to catching fire.
- Weathering Performance:
- Strongest against regular and extreme weather.
- Withstands strong winds, rain, snow, hail, AND ice.
- Low Maintenance:
- Requires minimal upkeep after correct installation.
- General upkeep only once or twice a year.
FUN FACT: Metal roofs can increase a building’s property value by 1-6%.
Cons of Metal Roofs
- Higher One-Time Cost:
- More expensive than shingle roofing upfront for both materials and labor
- Limited Qualified Contractors:
- Fewer installers are skilled to install metal roofing.
- Installer error is the source of nearly all potential problems.
- Oil Canning:
- Visible waviness in the flat areas of the metal panel.
- Does not affect performance.
- It is a visual drawback.
- Insurance Drawbacks:
- May lead to higher insurance premiums.
- A metal roof is more expensive to replace.
- Concerns exist around hail damage loss waivers
Shingle Roofs: Everything you need to know
A common choice. Everyone’s favorite. When people think of roofing, they think of shingles. But what is it about them that makes them special?
Pros of Shingle Roofs
- Economical in the Short Term:
- Cheaper than metal roofing as a one-time cost.
- Less than half the price. Appeals to homeowners focused on the upfront cost.
- Easier to Install & Replace:
- Requires less time and labor for installation and replacement.
- Shingles are prepackaged.
- Simply nailed to the roof deck.
- Less Expensive Repairs:
- Much cheaper to fix when damage occurs.
- Most shingles can be removed one at a time at the source of the issue.
- More Installers:
- Shingles are relatively simple to install.
- More contractors are available.
- Easier for consumers to find qualified installers.
- Foot Traffic:
- Shingles can be walked on by installers for easy handling and support.
- Provides greater traction for workers.
Cons of Shingle Roofs
- Short Lifecycle:
- Most shingle roofs last a maximum of 25 years.
- Frequent replacements (tear-off or layering) are common.
- Higher Long-Term Cost:
- Costs more over a long period because one metal roof outlasts at least three shingle roofs.
- Heavier:
- Asphalt shingles are heavier than metal panels.
- The extra weight puts stress on the building’s structure over time.
- Fire Concerns:
- Shingles contain asphalt. It is a material that catches.
- While rated Class A on the surface, the material is more likely to combust if a flame reaches the asphalt coating.
A Few Things to Keep in Mind
We have been dealing with clients for a long time, and this is what we tell all our clients.
- At the end of the day, choose a roof that fits your budget. If you are okay with your roof lasting up to 20 years, then go ahead with shingles. You would have to spend a lot on replacements, though. If you are willing to go broke once and have the relief of a lifetime, choose metal roofs. simple.
- Checking your environment is very important. If you are living in extreme weather, metal roofs are your friend.
- And of course, your building’s history matters as well. If it is an old building and you have to keep renovating it, use shingles. But for newer homes, metal roofing is the ideal choice.
Conclusion
Shingle roofs are popular for their affordability. NO DOUBT. But it’s important to understand its downside as well. Shingles may not always be the best long-term investment. Metal roofing has been around for a reason!
At Jensen & Son Roofing & Restoration, our experts can help you explore all your roofing options. We’re committed to helping homeowners make smart choices that protect their homes for years to come. LET’S BUILD A ROOF THAT WILL LAST YOU A LONG TIME.
FAQs
- Which is better metal roof or a shingle roof?
The lifespan of metal roofs is longer. Shingle roofs are affordable. So it really depends on your budget and convenience. Both are excellent choices.
- What’s the best type of roof to get?
Metal roofs are the best type of roof. They provide a relief of a lifetime. You do not have to keep repairing them.
- Are metal roofs noisy when it rains?
It is a common myth about metal roofs. It is actually not true at all. Metal roofs are not any noisier than other roofs when it rains.
- What type of roof adds the most value to a home?
Architectural shingles and metal roofs add the MOST value to your home. Contact Jensen & Son Roofing & Restoration, and our experts will properly guide you.
- What is the biggest problem with metal roofs?
Poor installation jobs can be a big problem with metal roofs. They require special techniques to install. You need to find a trusted contractor for this job.